Plain
Talk about Soap and Cosmetics Ingredients - by Caroline Sposto
There are many words on today’s soap and cosmetic labels. Some are
meaningful, some are "puffery," and some are debatable. At Paisley
& Company, we make every effort to keep our prices down and one
of the easiest, and most legitimate ways to do this is to simply
avoid charging for hype. Although our customers give our products
sincere and enthusiastic rave reviews on a daily basis, we don’t
believe in making exaggerated claims about the intensity or
longevity of our product benefits. This down-to-earth approach has
served us well.
Joanne Lapic and I (the co-founders of Paisley & Company)
started our line with a strong belief that soap and cosmetic
companies owe it to their customers to be responsible when it comes
to making product claims. Because we are both mothers of pre-teen
daughters, who are on the cusp of being bombarded by
appearance-related media messages, this issue hits close to home.
Although the FDA does a wonderful job protecting the health of
today’s consumer, it is important to understand that this
administration does not exercise strict control over
advertising and marketing copy when it comes to cosmetic products.
According to John E. Bailey, Ph.D., director of FDA's division of
color and cosmetics. "Image is what the cosmetic industry sells
through its products, and it's up to the consumer to believe it or
not."
This relative leniency makes for glamorous ads and enticing labels,
but it does little to protect the consumer from buying empty
promises. Since the cosmetic industry is selling to an increasingly
younger market, (not to mention that credit cards are being used by
a younger-than-ever demographic) we believe that consumer awareness
in this area is very important — so important that we actively
promote it.
In 1973, stating the ingredients in cosmetics on the labels first
became law, this change gave many consumers the impression that all
label copy is regulated, but this isn’t really the case. There are a
lot of words and phrases being printed on cosmetic packaging that
sound scientific or verifiable, when in fact, they are used with no
required accountability.
In order to make this easier, here are some of today’s most common
cosmetic industry buzzwords (words that you will not see on
Paisley & Company labels or ads) along with what they actually
mean. We hope it helps:
Allergy Tested — There is no government or official
definition of this phrase. Manufacturers are not required by law to
perform any specific tests or provide any data to substantiate this
claim. This label may therefore have different meanings on different
products. In reality all products can cause allergic reactions in
certain people.
Botanical — This literally means that the product is derived
from a plant source. The connotations of this word are
wholesomeness, but the reality is that unless the product is derived
from an animal or mineral source, it is somehow the product of a
plant. Table sugar, chocolate and coffee are all "Botanicals." If
this is the only reason you are paying more for a product, you may
want to reconsider.
Cruelty Free — These words imply that the finished soaps
and cosmetics have not been tested on animals. However, there is
no legal definition of this term, and no required verification of
its use, and therefore, it means whatever the advertiser wants it to
mean. Paisley & Company does not and will not test its
products on animals, but we don’t add the phrase "Cruelty Free" to
our labels or our ads. This is because we are sticklers for
accuracy. Stating a product is "Cruelty Free," we believe, implies
to the consumer that no ingredient used in the manufacturing process
was ever tested on animals in any stage of the game. It is nearly
impossible to verify this. Some companies go so far as to use this
phrase simply to mean that they do no testing in-house, meanwhile
they outsource to independent animal testing labs on a regular
basis.
Dermatologist Tested — Unless the ad or label tells you which
dermatologist did the testing, what they were testing for, and what
they discovered, (which they usually don’t) this phrase is vague and
means very little.
Environmentally Friendly or Environmentally Safe — These
terms in general imply that the product or the packaging is in some
way beneficial or harmless to the environment. However, there are no
legal or regulated standards for using these two phrases on labels
or in ads.
Hypoallergenic - While some products are less likely to cause
allergic reactions than others, the lack of firm standards, and the
highly personal nature of allergies means that every company can
make its own determination of what those words mean. The FDA does
not require cosmetic companies to substantiate this claim in any
way.
Natural — This word has no legal definition when used in
cosmetic and soap advertising or labeling. Presumably it means that
the product does not contain synthetic chemicals, but there is no
regulation over the use of this word. Also, there is no science
behind the concept that all natural ingredients are good for the
skin. (Poison Ivy is "all natural.")
Tested in our Laboratories — If the laboratory is funded by
the cosmetic manufacturer, it is not exactly independent or
unbiased. Often these words are used simply to justify very high
prices. We are not questioning the value of scientifically
testing cosmetic products, we are only stating that there is no
objective standards that a company must meet in order to make this
particular claim.
In addition to these price-boosting phrases, we want to
remind you to view all grandiose claims with a healthy skepticism.
Likewise, if a company tries to get your business by implying that
you need improvement, think again. If you have a daughter who is
developing an interest in beauty products, have fun reading and
debunking the ads and labels with her. Help her to develop an
effective health and beauty program that is enjoyable without
demanding an excessive amount of her time or money.
Last, but not least, remember that bath, spa and beauty products
should help you to carve out a luxurious little oasis in your life.
Enjoy fragrances, textures and the feelings that go with routinely
giving yourself the care you deserve.
INDULGE!
In our Kutztown store, we offer parties and workshops for groups of
all ages. (We have successfully hosted Brownie Scouts, Red Hats and
everyone in between.) One of our most popular workshops was
designed, by request, for Cadette Girl Scouts, to help them to earn
the "Fitness to Fashion" badge. This program teaches the scouts
about intelligent consumerism in the cosmetic aisle, as well as
healthy skin care. If you are interested in booking a Paisley
workshop, call our store (484) 646-9515, and ask to speak with
Joanne.
|
|
 |


| All lives can be, and should be, extraordinary! |


|
|